If that does not correct the behavior, and if the drive is also not detected by your computer, the blinking light is probably a symptom of a larger problem. If you like the western digital my book but want to save even more money, the seagate expansion desktop is for you. The latest update to the my book essential line is a case study in how to ruin a previously good product. Also, im not sure about this specific model, but most seagate drives have a 5year warranty, which is very good. Our latest edition features visual, easytouse, automatic, continuous backup software and drive lock security protection. The my book desktop hard drive also works great with acronis true image wd edition software to schedule full system backups. From my own experiences with those brands, my preference would be seagate. Seagate expansion 1tb external or western digital 1tb my book. Seagate freeagent desk st315005fda2e1rk and western digital my book essential wdbaaf0015hbknesn its hard to find accurate specs on them. This is quick unboxing of a seagate expansion usb 3. Wd mybook essential enclosure and non wd replacement drive. Password protection indicates whether the hard drive has password protection as a security measure against unauthorised entry. As for the models, i have heard good things about the wd and it has a competitive price point.
Smaller, sleeker and more elegant than previous my book external hard drives, the my book essential hard drive takes up minimal space on your desk. In conclusion, seagate hard disk drives are generally fast, fluent in reading and writing, and generally light. Among those external drives, western digitals my passport series and seagates backup plus portable drives are popular. This western digital my book hard drive offers builtin 256bit hardware encryption and optional password protection for peace of mind. Prior versions were a wd drive in a book like external usb drive case, with some optional software preloaded on the drive, that could be removed if you didnt need it. The western digital wd black 4 tb wd4003fzex also has 64 mib of cache and uses a sata600 interface, but spins at 7,200 rpm. Weve chosen the wd passport as our winner in this category because of its small, thin size. Cant seem to find anything on the net regarding this. Wd my passport ultra vs seagate backup plus slim vs toshiba vs hgst vs samsung january 1, 2015 storage hdd, portable, usb3 pretzel it is this authors opinion that 2015 should be the year of the backup. Discover the perfect backpack, dorm room decorations, study supplies and great external hard disk drives to prepare for going back to college. Never answer quora questions when youre under the influence of s. Seagate vs western digital what are the differences on storage. Always download file by yourself, directly from wd web page, put it on your computer or even on usb device if you have my cloud and update it directly through web browser user interface.
Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as wd elements or wd my passport ultra 1tb. Other than the new design, the drive doesnt have much to elevate it above others. Designed to meet wds demanding requirements for durability, shock tolerance, and longterm reliability, we back up pun intended. I would like to be sure i dont lose data and after reading my book drives. What is the difference between seagate expansion and seagate backup plus external hard drive. After 20 hours of new research and testing, we found that the best external desktop hard drive for most people is western digitals 4 tb my book. Wd my passport ultra 500gb is a very popular option in the middle of the external hard drives price range. I prefer the design and bit lower price of the seagate, but actual performance and long term reliability is more important for me. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd 4tb my book desktop usb 3. Because im still dizzy from the anesthesia from last weeks surgery. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as wd my passport ultra 1tb or wd elements. May 16, 2007 as for the models, i have heard good things about the wd and it has a competitive price point. Whether by chance or calculated planning, both seagate and wd recently released 4tb portable external hard disk drives. The my book is reliable, fast, and less expensive than the other desktop drives we tested, plus it has enough space for your future storage needs and a long, threeyear warranty.
Thinking the enclosure was bad, i put in a wd drive to test it and it mounts just fine. We pit the two against each other to find out which is better. Wd elements 2tb vs seagate goflex 2tb ars technica. Dec 02, 2015 my book drives encrypt everything on the drive even if you dont specify a password. Which is better wd my passport ultra or seagate expansion. Seagate vs western digital what are the differences on. Feb, 2017 wd mybook essential 2017 6tb unboxing jailbreakmodo. I got some opportunity to get either seagate backup plus hub 8 tb external hard drive or western digital. Im a very much confused between wd my book 4tb external hard drive. If you are considering purchasing an external hard drive, the following seagatewestern digital is worth buying. Seagate backup portable is a popular option in the middle of the external hard drives price range. The best external hard drives you can buy in 2020 the telegraph. And there is enough space for your hdd ssd and usb cable. Wd elements should be good, but stick clear of the passport and mybook lines.
When comparing seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive vs wd my passport, the slant community recommends wd my passport for most people. Does anyone know a way to reset or reconfigure the wd mybook to work with a non wd i. Its 5 gbps data transfer rate enables fast copying of files, and its automatic backup software can be set to fit any schedule. The wd my passport ultra is a great portable drive, and its included software bundle makes data backup a breeze. By contrast, the best seagate can muster is 10tb of storage from the singledrive backup plus hub amazon or expansion desktop. The most important reason people chose wd my passport is. Wd my book vs seagate expansion 4tb toms hardware forum. I need to transfer a lot of data between a few machines. I like the idea of being able to change the hard drive on my own, something the seagate doesnt make easy. You can even double them up and let them sit neatly together like volumes on your shelf. Only a case, do not include a hddsd or other accessories.
My book duo desktop raid storage wd discovery software for wd backup, wd security and wd drive utilities usbc to usbc cable usbc to usba cable ac adapter disk replacement tool quick install guide. The hdd of western digital is relatively stable with low hard drive. The western digital my book new 4tb has a password protection, but the seagate expansion external hard drive 4 tb does not. If you are considering purchasing an external hard drive, the following seagate western digital is worth buying.
Hi, im going to get a new computer with a 1tb hard drive and i plan on getting a 1tb. Seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive vs wd. The devices on this page represent the best among their respective. Which external hard drive is better, seagate or wd elements, and. It has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as lacie d2 quadra v3 or wd my book. Wd my book is a very popular and one of the more expensive options. Among those external drives, western digitals my passport series and seagate s backup plus portable drives are popular. While wds my passport pro offers thunderbolt connectivity, seagates backup plus fast is adamant that usb 3. Format the my book drive, open up the encloser and intstal that drive in to my new toy the my cloud. Portable external hard drive external hard disk drives. The mammoth 8tb capacity on the wd 8tb my book is the largest i have seen to date of this size in terms of dimension, as it measures only 170mm by 140mm. Users browsing for external hard disk drives usually look at.
If those steps do not return the drive to correct function, it is very possible, even probable, that the drive has failed and needs to be replaced see our warranty page to check the warranty. Considering getting a 3gb external hard drive for backup and storage. Oct 15, 2015 i have my cloud now and do not want to change back to my book live. Western digital has taken a more is better approach with its latest iteration of the wd my book essential hdd. May 24, 2017 the mammoth 8tb capacity on the wd 8tb my book is the largest i have seen to date of this size in terms of dimension, as it measures only 170mm by 140mm. Also, im not sure about this specific model, but most seagate drives. Oct 11, 2016 wd unveiled today its latest desktop external hard drive the wd my book. I think the seagate is 7200 rpm with a 32mb cache, and i cant find any numbers for western digital. Password protection, raid support and hardware encryption arent essential, but theyre nice to see. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd 4tb.
Western digital wins out when it comes to larger capacities, offering its my book duo with 20tb of storage in either a raid 0 or raid 1 configuration, along with plenty of connectivity. The seagate is a solid drive though as well i recommend seagate drives in general most times. Western digital wins out when it comes to larger capacities, offering its my book duo amazon with 20tb of storage in either a raid 0 or raid 1 configuration, along with plenty of connectivity. Seagates smaller drives are reliable and speedy and offer great value for money. I have a spare wd mybook enclosure and a spare 500gb seagate sata drive. Seagate vs western digital posted in external hardware. The wd mybook duo range builds up from 3 tb to 24 tb, with. Basically, the elements is wds answer to the seagate expansion drive. Wd unveiled today its latest desktop external hard drive the wd my book. My question is that it seems as if i can only put a wd drive in the mybook enclosure. The top model features a single 4tb drive and a usb3. It seems that when i put that drive in the mybook enclosure it does not mount. And it doesnt have to be plugged in to an outlet, so you can use this on the go. After testing seven hard drives, we found that western digitals 4 tb my book is the best external desktop hard drive for most people.
Hello friends, im going to buy an external 4tb hdd. Like its predecessors in the essentials line, the my book is marketed primarily as a backup storage device. Seagate backup portable was released last year in august. Apr 21, 2020 the readwrite speed of western digital hdds is a little slower compared with seagate, but it is more suitable for storage due to its good stability and durability. Which external hd should i buy, wd my passport ultra vs. I work with wd, hitachi, seagate, samsung, and toshiba hard drives. Millions of people around the world trust their data to my book desktop storage.
Store files securely with this 4tb western digital my book hard drive. Anyall advice on choosing between the two is welcomed. Hard drives from large companies like wd and seagate are going to be fine. Seagate goflex 3tb western digital my book essential 3tb usb 3. Nov 19, 2012 western digital has taken a more is better approach with its latest iteration of the wd my book essential hdd. Equipped with wd backup software for windows and apple time machine compatibility for mac, the my book desktop hard drive can back up your photos, videos, music and documents. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd. Seagate expansion or wd mybook for external hard drive. Wd my passport is ranked 4th while seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive is ranked 6th. The my book is reliable, fast, and less expensive than the other desktop drives we tested, plus it has enough space for your future storage needs and a. This means if you take the drive out of the enclosure and connect it directly via sata or put it in another enclosure, the data you read will be scrambled and unusable. Both seagate and western digital offer pocket external hard drives with different capacities and connectivity.
1439 1034 833 1294 873 144 780 890 1478 1133 167 1342 770 886 1122 927 1146 1052 1289 1014 335 1243 71 275 1508 1366 492 1193 1203 1476 779 119 233 21